a city is not a tree

admin15年前城市规划论文1814

The tree of my title is not a green tree with leaves. It is the name of an abstract structure. I shall contrast it with another, more complex abstract structure called a semilattice. In order to relate these abstract structures to the nature of the city, I must first make a simple distinction.

I want to call those cities which have arisen more or less spontaneously over many, many years natural cities. And I shall call those cities and parts of cities which have been deliberately created by designers and planners artificial cities. Siena, Liverpool, Kyoto, Manhattan are examples of natural cities. Levittown, Chandigarh and the British New Towns are examples of artificial cities.

It is more and more widely recognized today that there is some essential ingredient missing from artificial cities. When compared with ancient cities that have acquired the patina of life, our modern attempts to create cities artificially are, from a human point of view, entirely unsuccessful.

Both the tree and the semilattice are ways of thinking about how a large collection of many small systems goes to make up a large and complex system. More generally, they are both names for structures of sets.

In order to define such structures, let me first define the concept of a set. A set is a collection of elements which for some reason we think of as belonging together. Since, as designers, we are concerned with the physical living city and its physical backbone, we must naturally restrict ourselves to considering sets which are collections of material elements such as people, blades of grass, cars, molecules, houses, gardens, water pipes, the water molecules in them etc.

When the elements of a set belong together because they co-operate or work together somehow, we call the set of elements a system.

For example, in Berkeley at the corner of Hearst and Euclid, there is a drugstore, and outside the drugstore a traffic light. In the entrance to the drugstore there is a newsrack where the day's papers are displayed. When the light is red, people who are waiting to cross the street stand idly by the light; and since they have nothing to do, they look at the papers displayed on the newsrack which they can see from where they stand. Some of them just read the headlines, others actually buy a paper while they wait.

This effect makes the newsrack and the traffic light interactive; the newsrack, the newspapers on it, the money going from people's pockets to the dime slot, the people who stop at the light and read papers, the traffic light, the electric impulses which make the lights change, and the sidewalk which the people stand on form a system - they all work together.

From the designer's point of view, the physically unchanging part of this system is of special interest. The newsrack, the traffic light and the sidewalk between them, related as they are, form the fixed part of the system. It is the unchanging receptacle in which the changing parts of the system - people, newspapers, money and electrical impulses - can work together. I define this fixed part as a unit of the city. It derives its coherence as a unit both from the forces which hold its own elements together and from the dynamic coherence of the larger living system which includes it as a fixed invariant part.

Of the many, many fixed concrete subsets of the city which are the receptacles for its systems and can therefore be thought of as significant physical units, we usually single out a few for special consideration. In fact, I claim that whatever picture of the city someone has is defined precisely by the subsets he sees as units.

Now, a collection of subsets which goes to make up such a picture is not merely an amorphous collection. Automatically, merely because relationships are established among the subsets once the subsets are chosen, the collection has a definite structure.

To understand this structure, let us think abstractly for a moment, using numbers as symbols. Instead of talking about the real sets of millions of real particles which occur in the city, let us consider a simpler structure made of just half a dozen elements. Label these elements 1,2,3,4,5,6. Not including the full set [1,2,3,4,5,6], the empty set [-], and the one-element sets [1],[2],[3],C4],[5], [6], there are 56 different subsets we can pick from six elements.

Suppose we now pick out certain of these 56 sets (just as we pick out certain sets and call them units when we form our picture of the city). Let us say, for example, that we pick the following subsets: [123], [34], [45], [234], [345], [12345], [3456].

What are the possible relationships among these sets? Some sets will be entirely part of larger sets, as [34] is part of [345] and [3456]. Some of the sets will overlap, like [123] and [234]. Some of the sets will be disjoint - that is, contain no elements in common like [123] and [45].

以上应该是城市并非树形的节选,并非全文,也没有找到翻译。

相关文章

鲁尔工业区的蜕变(上)介绍

这个文章不能算观后感,只能算一个仔细观看后的回忆记录。 德国鲁尔工业区转型的背景是知识经济的崛起,工业不再是国力强盛的代表,特别是重工业逐渐的颓败。产业结构调整,劳动力转移,工厂被废弃,环境被破...

景观风水应该遵循十大原则

景观风水应该遵循十大原则 风水理论是什么呢?实际上就是地理学、地质学、星象学、气象学、景观学、建筑学、生态学以及人体生命信息学等多种学科综合一体的一门自然科学。其宗旨是审慎周密地考察、了解自然环境,...

浅谈小城镇用地规划的可持续性(转)

发展小城镇,提高城镇化水平,是“十五”计划纲要确定的一项战略任务,也是促进农民增收和国民经济良性循环的一项重大举措。以小城镇为重要载体,推 进农业现代化、农村工业化和农村城镇化,对国民经济可持续发展和...

中国城市规划现状

中国城市规划现状 2004年初,北京市交通管理部门首次承认首都交通规划的失败是造成城市交通不畅的主要原因。北京作为我国的首都,半个世纪的发展结果却成了“集中体现了20世纪建筑和城...

刘家海:行政规范性文件的司法审查与司法适用(转)

行政规范性文件的司法审查与司法适用 ——兼论行政诉讼审查标准体系的重构 (刘家海)   【摘要】国务院《全面推进依法行政实施纲要》规定,行政机关实施行政管理,应当依照法律、法规、规章的规定进行;...

推进城镇化需要深入研究的重大问题--李克强

推进城镇化需要深入研究的重大问题 --李克强 [提要]  城镇化是中国现代化进程中一个基本问题,是一个大战略、大问题。推进城镇化,面临的重点难点问题很多,不 少问题没有现成答案,各地情况又...